≡ Menu

Herding Cats

This academic year I have been a coach for a First Tech Challenge (FTC) Team; as the father of a high school student, I stepped in to fill a void – and to spend time with my son

The Mighty Team 10565

I am one of two coaches – Jan is another parent (and a now-retired professor) who has the time and the motivation to help. We’re supported by awesome volunteers. Club manager, Kari, who handles much of the back-end coordination that impacts all four teams, like registration and finances. And true specialists, our technical mentors, who volunteer their time and skills to help the kids with things that range from CAD to programming to machining and building.

Jan and I? We herd the cats. She and I do everything else that is needed – from rides to paperwork to phone calls to rosters. We answer questions, poke and prod. Being a coach meant joining a team of adults that make this happen. 

Great opportunities to talk about the engineering process

As coaches, we start the new year generating knowledge. Some of it is about the FTC challenge itself, since it changes every year. Some of it is about the specifics of the rules – they also change every year. But some of it is invariably about the engineering and design process.

I defer to our technical experts who live, breath, and eat this process every day. They gladly come in and translate the process into simple, easy to understand concepts, terms and language. It’s a review for returning students and an introduction for new kids.

Jan and I took the opportunity at the beginning of the year to lead the team through several rounds of the design process. We focused on the team identifying key requirements for the robot design by phase before they even laid hands on pieces. Team 10565 had two returning members – the rest were new students, mostly freshmen, and we knew this would be important both in giving them goals for their build but also in modeling success they could replicate later.

Jaren getting his build on

Great opportunities to not practice the engineering process.

Team 10565 did not use the engineering and design process much. Jan and I had many laughs about this, and the technical mentors would shake their heads and cover their eyes. The kids were building in accordance with their original designs, but they weren’t evaluating and redesigning based on identified needs for change.

And that was fine. Jan and I had some heart-to-hearts about this. This was our first (and potentially only) year coaching, and while we could bring up the topic of the design process, forcing it would clearly be counterproductive. It wasn’t our robot, it wasn’t our design, it wasn’t ours to fail – it was theirs. We worked with the mentors – who moved between all four teams – discussing what was happening and our concerns, what could be done or what should be done, and even at times how to indirectly influence things.

But our team liked to reinforce failure. They would take a bad design element and keep adding on to it, trying to polish it and polish it, with the hopes that maybe something it’d work out. Why? Because using the engineering and design process is work. Well, it sounds like work. Doing it right is work. It’s super easy if you don’t do it.

And that was our team this year. And that was OK.

The robots? Way cool.

Our robots were incredible anyway. The challenge this year called for figuring out ways to launch over-sized wiffle-balls, lift giant yoga balls up and place them into specific positions, and press buttons on beacons. The bots had to do some of these tasks autonomously. When I was their age, I was throwing rocks at cans, autonomously.

We put no limits on the students. As I mentioned, almost all of the kids of Team 10565 were new to the robotics program, and most had no or little experience with tools and/or power tools. Time to learn. We encouraged them to translate their design ideas into reality through material considerations as well as the use of the rights tools and safety measures.

Our team struggled with throwing the over-sized wiffle-balls. They designed and built seven different mechanisms to address this specific task. Seven. After the competition had ended, they continued to work on it – they’re on version nine as I write this.

The autonomous capabilities of their robot was head and shoulders above that of nearly every other robot they encountered. In the initial design process, the kids had specified autonomous movement as being a key and critical capability, because of how they saw it impacting gameplay. They identified this, and they decided this. And when it came time for the tournaments they were right. They were absolutely right.

Emmett, our team mascot

Is it a club? Is it a class? Is it a sport? Is it a competition?

Team 10565 advanced all the way to the Super-Qualifier Tournament – one of three Wilson High School teams to do so. One other team advanced to the FTC Oregon State Championship, and one advanced to the Western U.S. Super Regional Championship – finishing as one of the top 3% of the FTC robotics teams in the country.

Is that what we’re about?

No. Our program is most definitely a club activity. Wilson only began to offer a “robotics” class this year, but it’s not connected to the club robotics program. Ours is a serious and inclusive program, but it’s a club – a Smash Bros game might break out. The kids vote with their feet. They decide every week if they still want to be involved with their team, and the teams are entirely self-funded through fund-raising efforts.

As a coach? I can nurture that. I vote with my feet every week, too. I roll up my sleeves and get my hands dirty. I, for one, welcome our robot overlords.


Art La Flamme is a former Army officer who spent 25 years working in intelligence. He currently teaches intelligence and security studies at Angelo State University, emphasizing tech not just for spying but for research and collaboration.  Follow him on twitter at @artlaflamme or artlaflamme.com

Let Paperslide Into Your Class

Isn’t it great when you walk away from a keynote with something you can actually use immediately?

This is what happened when I saw Lodge McCammon give the closing keynote at IntegratED IPDX 2017 in February. He introduced us to Paperslides, a new-to-me combining of the low tech paper-glue-and-scissors we all love and miss with the ease and versatility of making videos for flipped or blended learning.

At this point you’re probably thinking, “These sound interesting, Doug. But what exactly are they?” That’s an excellent question, Dear Reader. And I could spend a lot of words explaining paperslides to you. But that isn’t nearly as neat (or meta) as actually using a paperslide video to explain. And with that I turn it over to Paper Courson and Paper Sophie-

This was made, all told, in about two and a half hours. But that’s because my student teacher Veronica and I got caught up in the fun and it got a little more detailed than we initially planned. But it went exactly like my paper monsters explained. I scripted the whole thing out, we decided what needed slides made, sketched out what the basic plan was, and got to cutting and gluing. We rehearsed twice and shot it in one take. Honestly, the hardest part was figuring out how to get the iPad we used in the correct position without letting it fall on Veronica’s head.

Precarious much? Really though, that was the best way to get everything framed properly.

But it’s not cool if you show your students how to do something and then don’t allow them to do it. After all, the goal of any nifty teacher tech is to hand it to students so they can create. At the same time Veronica and I had been banging our heads against the converting units section of our math standards. Yes, there’s giving the kids all the different measuring implements and letting them go to town, but we’ve got a big group. There had to be a more efficient way. Enter paperslides, one of those wonderful moments of serendipity that happen in classrooms. We (she- hey, she’s a student teacher, she needs to practice this stuff) broke the class into groups of three and assigned each group a one step conversion to represent using a paperslide. This allowed the kids to practice converting units by explaining the process, while also allowing them to make a paperslide video, while also keeping them from going completely overboard with their first paperslide video and thus keeping the timeframe tight and focused.

They were given a little under an hour total to design, rehearse, and shoot a class-wide paperslide video. This is what we ended up with after the hour-

It’s not the prettiest thing in the world, but it wasn’t meant to be. And now we have a student-created review and a new type of presenting learning that the kids are clamoring to use again. So much so that we just wrapped up some vocabulary reviews using a slightly more time-intensive version of the technique. That first, whole class one though, that was a fun challenge to set up and shoot. Felt like a baby OK Go video*.

Oy, did my back hurt by the end though

The combination of simple video making, incredibly high student engagement and creativity, and ease of set-up and execution makes paperslide videos something I’m going to keep in my Teacher Pocket for a long time to come. Steal my Courson and Sophie video. Show your kids. Make good things.

If you think this is cool, you should check out Dr. McCammon’s videos. They’re ridiculous.

*side note- if you’re not using Ok Go videos to inspire students to get to the making, you’re doing it wrong.

Doug Robertson is the CUE Blog Editor and an eleventh-year teacher currently talking at fifth graders in Northern Oregon. He’s taught in California, Hawaii, and Oregon in 3rd, 4th, and 6th grades. He’s the author of two books about education, He’s the Weird Teacher and THE Teaching Text (You’re Welcome), one novel, The Unforgiving Road, and is an active blogger. Doug speaks at teaching conferences including CUE Rock Star Teacher Camps, presenting on everything from technology to teaching philosophy (or teaching The Weird Way, to use his words).  Doug is also the creator and moderator of #WeirdEd on Twitter, which happens every Wednesday at 7pm PST.

Herding Robots – the life and times of a robotics coach

This academic year I have been a coach for a First Tech Challenge (FTC) Team; as the father of a high school student, I stepped in to fill a void – and to spend time with my son I am one of two coaches – Jan is another parent (and a now-retired professor) who has the […] Read More

Let Paperslide Into Your Class

Isn't it great when you walk away from a keynote with something you can actually use immediately? This is what happened when I saw Lodge McCammon give the closing keynote at IntegratED IPDX 2017 in February. He introduced us to Paperslides, a new-to-me combining of the low tech paper-glue-and-scissors we all love and miss with […] Read More

Breaking Into Breakout EDU

What exactly is this Breakout EDU thing I keep hearing about? You may have heard about escape rooms, where you pay someone to lock you and your friends in a room and you must collaborate to solve puzzles within the time limit in order to escape. People do this for fun! And they actively seek […] Read More

Blending Together – Creating and Bringing Videos Into Class

Today I asked my students who their favorite musicians are. It was a natural extension of a conversation we were having that sprang from the curriculum and I was genuinely curious. I am an Old, and I don't know what The Kids are into these days. I mean, Taylor Swift is my jam, but other […] Read More

Get in the Game(ification) With Five Games

This year at the CUE 2017 National Conference there were a lot of sessions on the topic of gamification, a strategy for increasing student engagement by applying game design principles to a classroom setting. After my presentation, several people came up to me and said that they were very interested in gamification, but they felt […] Read More

Your Internet History is Now For Sale

Most of us are acutely aware of the fact that everything you do on the Internet can be monitored and tracked by your Internet Service Provider (ISP). Every site you visit, how long you spend on the site, what you click on, etc., can be logged and is typically maintained by your ISP. And it […] Read More

A Look Back- CUE 2017 National Conference (Plus Puppets)

Looking back on CUE 2017, I am struck by the number of small moments in a venue so large it requires maps and guides. With nearing 8000 attendees, how could I possibly compose a reflection post that accurately describes CUE?   For those readers who have attended in the past, but didn’t make it this […] Read More

#CUE17- The Game

For the past few years, I’ve had the pleasure and honor of working on CUE conferences, mostly from afar at my homebase outside of Chicago, Illinois. My role has been to monitor social media, contribute to virtual conversations, and share ideas and resources with the #notatcue folks who are participating from a distance. I’ve also […] Read More